valiant ds9 reddit

GIVEAWAY: WIN AN ART … Once that's proven out, build Andromedas and Pathfinders. I think the warp 3.2 was from battle damage though wasn't it, like it normally could go faster? They were too absorbed into a cult-like mentality. The whole exploration vs. military thing is a weird dichotomy... My point is never to underestimate fanaticism. [Valiant sickbay] WATTERS [OC]: Take a look around. Throughout the entirety of Star Trek there are few crews as hated as the USS Valiant’s Red Squad. Never mind the fact that I do not think Acting-Captain Watters would simply accept being replaced. Not when there are more than enough qualified officers in all of Starfleet to do so. This episode was all set up for the stupid kids to jump in and save the day, only for reality to crash the party and show us what really happens when a bunch of cadets try to take on a far superior ship. Following Watters without question, the belief in the superiority of Red Squad (even amongst the Vulcan cadets), and how they reacted to Jake, all struck me as very poor. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Press J to jump to the feed. It was too easy. It might have worked if they had cast the cadets a little better and had the 'captain' actually be a compelling and inspiring leader, but instead he was just some twat. Everything else you said is spot on though. 629 DS9 Tears of the Prophets . Wesley finds love, Data learns lessons, and Bashir meets his match, while Picard and Sisko play war with the new girl. So yeah, the whole episode shouldn't have happened. The warp 3.2 was mentioned as they've "never" been able to go faster. I'm more bugged by him being promoted to Lt. Outlander's Ronald D. Moore on the challenges of writing Star Trek for film today, the state of the franchise, and Section 31 pitches. Watters is a total twat, but the ship was attacked and all te officers were killed. This show is the perfect examination of groupthinks/circle-jerkery. Review by Jamahl Epsicokhan "You're here to write the story—to tell people of the Valiant and her crew. Nog should have immediately took command of the Valient. 625 VOY One. I would have LOVED to see that episode. Deep Space Nine ... ranging from the stupid Time’s Orphan to the downright aggravating Valiant. 628 DS9 The Sound of her Voice . Deep Space Nine is typically considered a hard-hitting, gritty entry in Star Trek’s canon. Added scenes and visits to DS9 are included. Is it meant to imply that those previously behind Red Squad are still pulling the strings? There were a total of 176 episodes over the show's seven seasons, which are listed here in chronological order by original airdate, which match the episode order in each season's DVD set.. Or at least… that’s what it seems like they were doing. Take it in. I just watched this episode, again. Only a commissioned flag officer could take command of a ship where the captain was a field commissioned commander. The writing was a little choppy and the actors were - how best to say this - often "overwrought." Also in the real world, cadets would not be allowed to touch the ship without supervision, and only on limited terms (pleasure cruise only of no consequence). The dynamic in the beginning, with Quark pining over Dax is just weird. In this video I review episode 22 of Season 6 of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine "Valiant" Even if another ship with a real, commissioned Captain in charge showed up, "Captain" Watters would have likely ignored any orders and continued on his self appointed mission. ... Maybe a little slash fic. Also in the real world, the previous captain should have ordered the cadet to get the ship back to the federation territory as soon as possible - wasting a Defiant-class vessel by letting inexperienced children command it unsupervised should have been criminal in a time of war. Watters takes command, gets the ship righted in a stressful situation, and people blindly followed. It's just one of the episodes that really bugged the hell out of me. No slash fic. Members: Billy Storm (First Tenor), Sheridan Spencer (second tenor), his cousin Brice Coefield (Baritone) and Chester Pipkin (Guitarist). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_IMBUa7w9K4. A subreddit for in-depth discussion about Star Trek. DS9 pays homage to “Lord of the Flies” with a story about the collapse of values in the face of authoritarianism. Also in the real world, the previous captain should have ordered the cadet to get the ship back to the federation territory as soon as possible - wasting a Defiant-class vessel by letting inexperienced children command it unsupervised should have been criminal in a time of war. "Captain" Watters was beyond logic and reason at that point. I pretty sure you're misinterpreting what was said in the episode. And why obey orders from another person with the rank of Captain? Where between the Starbase and Ferenginar does this incident take place, given that it's apparently under complete Dominion control? “Valiant Effort,” an upcoming PC game that takes players into the skies of occupied Europe during WWII, was announced earlier this month by developer Sharp End Studio. Wouldn't there just be a single explosion? They didn't need a qualified crew of officers and servicemen to do it. Why was Riley Shepard, who sabotaged Earth's power as part of a failed coup, still in Starfleet, let alone trusted with a mission like this? Reddit 0 In part one and two, we witnessed the birth of the STARSHIP VALIANT fan series, the brainchild of Oklahoma City-based Michael L. King. Comicstorian Makes Comic Writing Debut in BLOODSHOT #12 This March. The SS Valiant (NCC-S1104) was a galactic survey cruiser that was launched from Earth in 2065.She was one of the first warp driven deep space explorers deployed by Earth and was commanded by Captain Carlos Tarasco.. Startrek.com gives the ship's launch date as 2064.. But I believe it's most dangerous when it affects the military or government. It is strongly implied that that limitation came as the result of battle damage. Set in the science fiction universe of Star Trek, this series focuses on the adventures of the crew of the titular space station Deep Space Nine in the 24th century. But the story of Starship Valiant goes back farther than that and starts with a fellow named MICHAEL L. KING. 627 VOY Hope and Fear. Directed by Michael Vejar. Appreciate the fact that you are on this ship, with this group of people, at this point in history. He had already worshipped Red Squad - their role in the insurrection attempt nonewithstanding - and now he found that they had done (in his eyes) rather well for themselves in a war he knew all too much about. Also any transmissions should be securely encrypted. That sort of thing can lead to blind trust and arrogance. In the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode “Valiant”, Jake Sisko and Nog get up close and personal with a group of elite cadets who have been stranded behind enemy lines for nearly eight months. Many people in the past have pointed out that Nog, with an ensign's commission, outranked everyone on the ship and arguably could have asserted command. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. In conclusion, every redditor should watch this episode. Don't interfere with this story, Jake. In my opinion though, any … Yes, Starfleet isn't the 'military,' except that it is. I wouldn't say it's the worse DS9 episode. (DS9: " Valiant ") Members of Red Squad Usually this is limited to hate groups like Westboro or ISIS. And I don't mean look at the walls. Michael is considered my many fan filmmakers to be one of the nicest people in our entire community. I agree it's not the best episode but it is pretty entertaining either way. I think: I should go on reddit and ask if anyone knows. 630 VOY Night . You see it all the time in people who are so caught up in their own arrogance that they believe that they can not possibly be incorrect. After been suddenly beamed aboard the U.S.S. The writers eventually decided that if Kira was there she would have bashed too many heads and beat those punks into submission and flew the ship back herself if she had to. The fan series STARSHIP VALIANT has just released its latest episode, “Animals,” a fan film that got its start a little over three years ago in 2017. And although Star Trek doesn't have many examples, the courageous gang of youngsters taking on and soundly defeating a superior force of experienced and well trained enemies pops up pretty frequently in other franchises. I thought it hit right on Nog's infatuation with all things Starfleet, and represented one of two big turning points for his character (the other being when he got shot). DS9 had a bunch that really stand out like In the Pale Moonglight, The Siege of AR-558, The Visitor, etc Valiant is another one I remember well too which was a great standalone episode but in the context of the Dominion War. ... Reddit - … Valiant, a Defiant-class warship, Nog recognizes the crew as Red Squad, an elite corps of Starfleet cadets. But Hitler put huge rearming policies into effect which pulled the country out of a depression, so people just did whatever. Even if the cadets resisted that, Nog was still a commissioned officer and wouldn't try to be "cool" with some cadets. But befor… Continuity director fail. Why are Jake and Nog going through territory which has been held by the enemy for nine months in a runabout? DS9 S06:E21 "Valiant" and why I think it's one of the worst episodes ever. I've created a section for this topic on our Previous Discussions page: "Nog's rank in 'Valiant'". Given the behavior we saw from Red Squad, the best possible outcome for Nog, had he attempted to take command before the battle, would have been for him to end up in the brig with Jake. Between that, Threshold, Code of Honor, Profit and Lace, Shades of Grey, and The Alternative Factor, there has to be an episode you liked less than this one. Nothing happens as it does or would during any other episode. The first season, however, was uneven. The ship's crew was too far gone. After the names "The Sabers" and "Chavelles" in 1955 - … Why has nobody from the Federation or their allies noticed that a state-of-the-art Defiant-class ship, presumed missing, has in fact been right there all along? Image courtesy of ViacomCBS "I remember it being a … Not only that, but because he's Red Squad he's better than a regular Captain ranked officer! The circumnavigating the federation wasn't really a mission. I never really had an issue with Jake, but felt like punching him during it. They converse amiably, and Collins starts to tell him about her home of Tycho City on Luna. The Valsartan in Acute Myocardial Infarction (VALIANT) trial randomized 14,703 patients post-MI complicated by HF and/or LV dysfunction to valsartan, captopril or a combination of valsartan and captopril, and demonstrated that there was no significant difference in mortality among the … Take the rampant nationalism during Hitler's reign in Nazi Germany. There should've been an entire crew in there the entire time, and the cadets get a tour while the Valiant is in dock or a single day trip only. Sort of the same thing here, though of course drastically less evil. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine is an American science fiction television series created by Rick Berman and Michael Piller.It originally aired from January 1993 to June 1999, in syndication, spanning 176 episodes over seven seasons. Fun fact: The original concept was to have Kira instead of Jake. No, wait, I don't need to, I have the blueprints. Nog could have been a Vulcan and still would have ended up in the brig had he tried to take command. They wouldn't try to circumnavigate the Federation in a ship that is Experimental like the Defiant, and could only reach warp 3.2. Little real world info: I believe they said when they were writing this episode that they were aware of how it would be in a modern navy (having a commissioned ensign outrank an acting captain), so instead decided to base it off of the 19th century British Navy, where only an admiral could relieve an acting captain. Don't become a part of it. If I recall correctly the design was made to fight the Borg, had some issues O'Brien fixed, and then began to be mass-produced - that is why when the original Defiant was destroyed there was another one to replace it. 626 DS9 Time's Orphan. The USS Valiant (NCC-74210) was assigned for training purposes for the Starfleet Academy cadets of Red Squad. I want you to look at this moment [Valiant Brig] WATTERS [OC]: In your life. It shows Dax in a belittling little-woman esque light. What possible sort of reason is there for maintaining radio silence when something as drastic as war being declared happened? I am pretty sure the Defiant stopped being experimental by that point in time. Isn't that entire plot of the first Abrams movie? The whole point of the episode is that Nog and the cadets were wrong, with disastrous effects. I think there's something to be said about the effects of fanaticism, which can be quite potent. Which would mean that they launched before the Defiant had finished its modifications. 622 DS9 Valiant . At the very least, a superior officer should be able to cite specific examples of incompetence, negligence and/or violation of laws or regulations in doing so. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. Deep Space Nine is more interested in the stories that can be told against the backdrop of the war than in telling the singular story of the war. For being "elite" cadets, every person on that ship was going to make a TERRIBLE Starfleet officer. She appears to be getting upset during the conversation, an… 631 VOY Drone . Why do the two standard torpedos (plus radiation) set off a massive chain of explosions which go across the whole length of the ship but leave it unharmed? The worst part of it is the huge jingoistic attitude of all the cadets. Cadets, no matter how elite, wouldn't think they could solely command a starship, which by circumstance, happens to have no surviving officers. It features many popular heroes and teams like Archer & Armstrong, Bloodshot, Harbinger, Ninjak, Shadowman, and X-O Manowar.Despite going out of business in the late 90's, Valiant has experienced huge critical acclaim since Valiant Entertainment has rebooted the universe in 2012. Hated the whole 'good vs evil' confrontation. Watch that episode, look me in the eye, and tell me that Valiant is worse. The Enterprise won't know what hit it. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Jake and Nog's runabout come under attack from the Jem'Hadar, and are rescued by the Valiant, a ship manned by Red Squad, an elite group of young Starfleet cadets. Valiant is a very bitter and mean-spirited little episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, and all the more effective for that fact.. And although I am generally not a big fan of blowing up ships full of kids, I think having an episode or two that hammer that point home is a good thing. Rated: T - English - Romance/Adventure - Chapters: 1 - Words: 3,964 - Published: 12/12 - J. Picard, Wesley C., OC. I don't know the math, but I bet that would be a ridiculous amount of time. VALIANT’S FIRST MOVIE BLOODSHOT MAY WIN AN OSCAR. A short teaser tr… I have a hard time believing that had the admiralty known the Valiant was still out there and not destroyed that they would have done anything except recall the training cruise immediately and put a veteran crew on board to take an advanced warship to the front lines. With Avery Brooks, Rene Auberjonois, Michael Dorn, Terry Farrell. "Valiant" is the 146th episode of the television series Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, the 22nd episode of the sixth season. That means he's a commissioned officer, just like Nog. It is an awful episode, IMO. Nog badly wanted into Red Squad, which was a subplot of some earlier episodes (Paradise Lost). This was a big stepping stone on the climb that leads to him becoming the level headed captain you mentioned below. Never would cadets in training would be put in risk. Everything is out of place. Chief Collins takes Jake to the mess hall, where he draws more than a few stares from the rest of the thirty three-man crew (being the only civilian on board). There are explosions and space battles aplenty in “Valiant,” but the episode’s single most important effect is its casting; specifically, the casting of the under-age crew of the titular Federation vessel. I believe that had he not died the original captain of the Valiant would have made contact with Starfleet. It presumably doesn't have a cloaking device, and is apparently a reasonable distance from a Starbase and Feringinar (and seemingly very close to the Starbase, unless the episode is just edited badly), yet it was never noticed. [Valiant Bridge] WATTERS: But understand one thing above all else. I'm probably overreacting but I welcome everyone's opinions. I like the fact that DS9 characters aren't perfect and that Nog disagrees with Jack even though he is wrong. 632 VOY Extreme Risk . I am not sure Acting-Captain Watters is being entirely truthful about the events. I thought the reason they were "circumnavigating the federation" was just an excuse to get them out of reach of Sisco after the cadets mission to blow up the power station in San Francisco. Once it was obvious that Red Squad was fucking up big time, Nog did take command, although it was too late to save the ship or most of its crew. “Valiant” (season 6, episode 22; originally aired 5/6/1998) In which we can be heroes, but just for one day… (Available on Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon.). Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The worst would have been summary execution for Mutiny in Time of War. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. "Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" Valiant (TV Episode 1998) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. It's really common in Star Trek to see some hackneyed desperation plan work perfectly and save our heroes, or have the commanding officer take a giant risk which pretty much always works. No, someone who clearly and obviously outranked Watters was the ship's, and the crew's only hope of survival. He was fixated on this mission beyond all reason. Although it can be frustrating to watch characters make bad decisions, I think this episode has a lot going for it. No. Then there's the security man who has two expressions - dumb smirk and anxious. It's definitely one of the worst episodes in my view. The characters we do know just aren't who they normally are. In the real world, yeah, Nog outranked out. I'm tempted to build a limited number of Vengeance class ships for defending core worlds/crucial forward operating areas, but only after the Borg attack in BOBW. I don't know the math, but I bet that would be a ridiculous amount of time. The Valiant Universe is a shared superhero universe originally created by Jim Shooter's Valiant Comics in 1991. On top of that the crew had a serious drug problem. You would hope that people wouldn't blindly follow a government that would commit the atrocities they did. 624 DS9 Profit and Lace . I think that Nog would have had grounds to do so, except for his lingering hero worship of the elite cadets; he may have also hesitated because he wasn't in the command division. Jake doesn't- maybe because he's not indoctrinated by the military? Star Trek news and discussion. "Deep Space Nine" was a bold concept for the Star Trek franchise and, by and large, it worked. It made me hate all of the characters, and just made no sense at all as I watched it. Never in the episode is stated that the ship left with only the ability to travel at warp three. More importantly, however, this episode is essentially a deconstruction of the old "pluck and bravery beat experience and training" trope, with a side helping of "risky gambles always work." This episode should make us think about scenarios where we seemingly blindly follow a pied piper. Quark saves it. Nog and Jake come aboard after almost being killed by the Jem'Hadar, Nog drinks the koolaid. They wouldn't try to circumnavigate the Federation in a ship that is Experimental like the Defiant. Commander, yet wearing Lt.JG pips. Big "agree" on that Nog stepped in line too quickly, but I think may also be because he has an obvious case of Hero worship. The writer explained it away using a reference to 17th and 18th century ships. While on the way to Ferenginar, Jake and Nog are attacked by a Jem'Hadar vessel. The stress, lack of training, isolation, drug problems, and echo-chamber would have made it impossible for anyone short of the rank of Admiral to take command back. I just watched this episode, again. All of the regular officers were killed. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the DaystromInstitute community. The Captain died the next day - He had ample time to give orders to head home but the way Watters acted, I am not sure he relied that information to the rest of the crew or talked those who overheard it out of obeying. Archer finds the hidden teachings of Surak. Valiant is an episode about a bunch of plucky young cadets who get brutally murdered for daring to believe in themselves. 633 VOY In the Flesh . Alexander Siddig as Dr. Julian Bashir in Star Trek Deep Space Nine episode "Our Man Bashir. Quark is a Ferengi - he has expressed disgust at the fact that women are even allowed to wear clothes. I'd build the Valiant first, mostly to make sure that it's possible to even build ships with these future tech designs. This strikes me as one of the worst episodes ever made for DS9. I'd say that is pretty in character for him.... Sure he would, he is characterized as hungry for approval and status in other episodes. It's not something that needed to be done, it's just something they were having their elite cadets do. It is an interesting episode, but should not have happened in the real world. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine "Valiant" Air date: 5/4/1998 Written by Ronald D. Moore Directed by Michael Vejar. You might be interested in some previous discussions on this topic: How legitimate are battlefield promotions? Just let it unfold around you. 623 VOY Demon. Nog wouldn't blindly follow some lunatic. The mission is hardly a mission at all, but an excuse by a higher up of dubious loyalties to get a bunch of useful criminals out of the reach of investigators until it is safe for them to go back to earth. ENT "Kir'Shara" on H&I. The cadet captain received a battlefield commission from the original Captain. After all, the Valiant had been reported missing for eight months - why would Starfleet send them orders? First, there's the plot, which made no sense to me. It was a really weak episode. The 22-year-old captain, Tim Watters, explains that his crew became trapped in Dominion space when the war broke out while originally on a training mission. 50's rhythm 'n' blues group formed in Los Angeles' Jordan High School. There's a hideous speech from Jake, delivered with smarm, about how awesome his dad is and how if he can't do it, nobody can. This started him on the road to understanding that even in fantastic organizations there are bad elements, and blindly leaping into something just because it's done under the supposed auspices of a group you respect is not a terribly good idea. You'd think by now that people would stop doubting Sisko when he says the Prophets spoke to him. Radio silence makes no sense, like you say. This strikes me as one of the worst episodes ever made for DS9. By that I mean the actors seemed unsure of themselves throughout much of this first season of this brand new series. In Watters' mind they both have the same rank, so he doesn't have to take orders from his peer. Some of that bitterness is baked into the basic premise. But hey, the destruction of the Valiant is pretty great, huh? In the real world, yeah, Nog outranked out. FAITH MOTION COMIC: WATCH EPISODE TWO NOW! The guest actors are terrible; notably the woman who delivers a line about the power being out with not only a whine, but a pout. Not to mention that Waters' decision making was clouded with drug use. and could only reach warp 3.2. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine is the third live-action television series in the Star Trek franchise and aired in syndication from January 1993 through June 1999. DS9 "The Reckoning" on H&I. Starfleet would never send cadets out on such a long mission, to "circumnavigate the federation". Go onto reddit … For one thing, Nog actually learns from his bad decision, which makes a big difference to my perception of it. Valiant Entertainment April 2021 Solicitations. Nothing seemed written correctly. Liked Kira with the blue contact lenses. I think that Starfleet may have changed the policy of letting officers arbitrarily pull rank after Commodore Matt Decker did that in "The Doomsday Machine" and endangered the Enterprise. Why have other trips to Ferenginar apparently been routine and without problems or any mention of this risk? Am I the only one that actually enjoy that episode? In 2374, crewed by 7 regular officers and 35 elite Red Squad cadets, it embarked on a training mission.

Wayne Gretzky Signing Events 2020, Comma Sign Radiology, Deimos Space Careers, Italy Rugby Results, District Collector Meaning In English, Duncan Total Drama Voice Actor, Pilot Pen Refill,